For as long as I can remember, Mom has loved the captive audience of a moving vehicle. In route to anywhere, she’d go over various character assassinations of family members. She had a great need to reinforce her point - and her point was to plant evil seeds, and watch them grow.
I learned to tune Mom out as she sat posing in the passenger seat of the car, bragging of her dominance and control, while reaffirming the stories. She made sure each time that I would get the impression that she couldn’t be wrong about these things. Mom had a way of insisting that this family member, or that, really was crazy, or that they did something horrible, which always in effect, affected Dad.
One afternoon, captive in the car, she crossed the line. She told me she wanted to see Susie. I didn’t know why she would even think of doing that, when she’d just months before gotten rid of her for the last time - and had been trashing Susie ever since.
Looking back now, though, I think she knew I was mostly tuning her out. Mom said that she was hoping that the next time Sue comes to Florida, I would include her. I wasn’t about to get woven into her web with this, and I didn’t want to feed this line of deceit, so I just listened.
Before I knew it, Mom started in with all the things she hated about Sue, which I always found puzzling because it was like she was talking about a different person - I didn’t see Sue in the same way at all. Mom went on during the drive of how Susie upsets Dad, and that Dad and she can’t handle it at their age. Through the windshield, my eyes scanned the roadway, and my mind said, “Won’t she just shut up!” She got rid of Sue once and for all - she should just leave it that way!!
Still, Mom went on. She said, “I can’t trust Sue to be alone with her. But if she were to stay with one of you girls, I would come to your house and see her. You know? I’m over that last blowup. I still want a relationship with her. I like Susie. She can be a lot of fun.” I was wondering what the hell she was talking about - I knew she hated Susie. All I got out of that was that she planned on having Sue return for a “visit” and keep her from seeing Dad - the only person Susie ever came to Florida to see.
As I drove down Silver Springs Boulevard I, decided to call Mom on her behavior with Sue, after all, she brought it up. Not understanding at the time why Mom and Sue had what Mom called “blowups”, I decided to be honest with her about what I thought could be the “problem”.
Merely guessing, I thought it made sense. “You know, Mom. That was not the first time you and Sue have had words. If you really want to have a relationship with her you’re going to have to apologize for her childhood.” Mom looked at me inquisitively. “What? What about her childhood?” I explained that every time she got back with Sue after throwing her out - she never apologized. She swept the past under the rug, eventually resulting in another explosion. Mom looked confused. I said, “You know. From the time Sue was five years old Dad screamed at her. He called her dumb, dumb, dumb. He hollered a lot to “Use your head Susan””!
Mom looked at me with a childish expression, and said, “What?! I don’t remember that. Was I there? I couldn’t have been there, or I would remember that”. I said, “You must have been. He said it all of the time. Almost every day.” Mom looked out the passenger side window and declared, “I don’t remember that. Are you sure?”
I think while Mom’s head was turned, looking out the window, she was hiding that childishly irresistible urge to grin. To her, this confrontation must have been amusing. Not being aware of her intentions, I was merely trying to come up with a solution, or an idea that might help understand why she‘s ended up throwing Susie out of the family so many times. What I’ve always thought was that once you understand something, it’s easier to fix. But this all amounts to just pure entertainment for Mom. Seeing me seriously trying to “fix” something that she’s made up (the “blowups”), satisfies Mom. All the while Susie, me, or Linda, tried to ‘fix’ the mess that Mom made of the family, she was busy dismantling the efforts. And if one of us was tenacious enough in doing so, Mom would promptly make something up about them and throw them out.
I said, “I know we remember things differently from our childhood, but even Joe mentioned it when he was home in April.” That caught her attention. She snapped her head in my direction. No longer satisfied, she had no grin. Without even skipping a beat, she calmly said, “What did he say?” I said, “Joe was at Linda’s kitchen table, and said that he couldn’t get the image of Susie being verbally abused out of his head. And worse, he said that you would laugh when it was happening! It has haunted him his entire life.” Mom sat still, just listening intently as if we were discussing tickets to a ball game. I added, “Joey still can’t forgive himself for not speaking up for Sue. I think that’s what needs to be addressed with Sue.”
Joey had been exiled from the family for thirty years, but Mom kept in touch by letters over the years - Joey rarely wrote her. Then in April, he and his wife decided to come back into the family when Dad’s lung disease took a turn for the worst. Suddenly, Joey was talking about coming to Ocala, Florida for the Winter, and possibly longer. Mom didn‘t want to mess things up with Joe - not then. She needed to study him some before being confident enough to manipulate him into self-destruction. And besides, she’d want to use him first.
Mom likes to get more bang for the buck when it comes to manipulation. Once she gets out of him what she wants - and it could take years - she’ll build up to the grand finale of destroying him emotionally.
“Well”, Mom exclaimed! Pretending to be surprised, “Out of all you kids, I thought Joey had it the worst. Your father couldn’t relate to him at all! I always felt bad for Joey.”
I couldn’t believe it! Mom totally washed over the fact that she laughed about her own little girl being verbally abused. Who does that to their own child - who does that period? By redirecting the conversation, Mom’s intention was to avoid addressing the incredible offense. Worse, she tries to show “empathy” for Joey, instead, which is attention getting - coming from her. It was distressing to see Mom playing this game. She spoke with such conviction, but her attempt at redirecting the conversation was obvious.
After Dad died, and I found out the truth about Mom, I looked back at this conversation with interest. Mom twisted everything. The truth is no one should be alone with Mom. There was no blowup on Sue’s part the last time she was in town. Mom hated Sue. Sue was the last person she wanted to see. Sue was fun for Mom in the past because she allowed Mom to manipulate her to the obvious crescendo of the kick-outs. But not anymore - Sue was no longer playing, and Mom knew it. Getting Sue to return would be just another challenge for Mom. She wanted to set Sue up again for another ‘kick-out’, just to relive the pleasure of her destruction.
I told Mom, “Well if you felt so sorry for Joey, then you should at least apologize to him, and make that right.” Ignoring my advice, instead, she continued on about Sue. “When Linda gets home from work, I want to ask her if she remembers that about Susie. If that’s true, I have no problem sitting down with you three girls and talking about it. The only thing I remember is calling Sue Aunt Betty.”
Then I remembered that “Aunt Betty” was the last name Mom ever called Sue - it was right after kicking her out of the family for the last time, some months ago.
I said, “Yeah, that’s a good one. Did you ever stop and think about the message you were giving her when you did that?” Mom didn’t respond. She just looked at me as if to say, ‘what’? “You always called her Aunt Betty, knowing Aunt Betty was the one person you had nothing good to say about. How do you think Sue felt?” Mom replied “Oh, I never thought about it THAT way.” She added, “I always call her Susie. That’s a term of endearment, you know. If I didn’t feel that way about her I’d call her Sue.”
I thought to myself - she never called her Susie to her face - but when speaking of her to others she did so in order to create the impression that she thought of her endearingly. That way when she kicked her out of the family, everybody might question Susie’s innocence. After all, Mom loved her.
We pulled onto Mom’s driveway and said goodbye. I went home thinking about the absurd conversation with Mom, and her cavalier attitude about child abuse. It was sickening.
That night Linda called me, and I told her about the conversation with Mom. She said, “Oh my GOSH, Debbie.” I told her that Mom didn’t believe me about Sue’s child abuse, and that she wanted to ask her about it. Linda’s wheels started spinning. “I don’t know. I don’t want to get in the middle of it. You know, when I point things like that out to her she turns on me. I don’t know if I want to deal with her. I’ve been trying to avoid Mom’s traps. Lately, things have been pretty good because I am not letting her get to me.” I dropped the subject right there, and we soon were onto another topic, less irritating.
Weeks went by before the subject was broached again - and oddly enough, it wasn’t either one of us to bring it up.
It was a few weeks later, when after returning from work one day, Linda and I arranged to take Mom to the park pool for an outing of sorts. All was well as we enjoyed some small-talk, splashing away carefree. Then, Mom floated over to Linda, and with her hands together, fingers folded inside one another, she squiggled her arms in front of her like a snake, approaching it’s prey. Mom said in a righteous, indignant tone, “I want to ask YOU.” She looked at me, and said, “What was it you said in the car about Sue and when she was little?” I said, “No. You can tell Linda. I’m not saying it. You tell her Mom. I’ll correct you if you don’t get it right.” Mom gave me a look of contempt, but she had already opened her mouth. She started talking to Linda about Susie and the times she threw her out - and how she deserved it. Mom pounded it out until she got Linda to nod like she believed Mom, and Mom was RIGHT. Then she led into my confrontation with her in the car, about Susie being verbally abused. Of course she didn’t remind Linda of her laughing about Susie’s tears at the time, for she was leading Linda to side with her.
Mom said, “Is that true? Did we abuse Sue? I don’t remember.” Knowing this was coming, Linda tried to answer without getting Mom mad. “Yes. She was yelled at a lot. Dad called her dumb. You know, we never knew what kind of a mood Dad would be in when he got home.”
Mom instantly went into one of her tirades, splashing the water on the pool surface away from her body, and then grabbing the edge of the pool to lift herself up into a more controlled posture. “I can’t believe it! Seventy-five years old and I’m being questioned. At this age I have to talk to you kids and apologize for something that happened so many years ago? That’s ridiculous! Why do I have to apologize for something your father did?”
She then raised her voice, and trying to redirect the conversation, she said that her father abused her. “You kids, I TELL YOU my father did terrible things to me. I NEVER told anyone. That’s how it was back then, people didn’t talk about those things.”
As usual, Mom couldn’t resist pulling out her Ace in the hole, Linda, to make it all go away. She was positive that Linda would lie for her as usual, but when this time Linda half rode the fence - Mom reacted like a spoiled child.
I was surprised when Mom changed the focus from her to Dad, and when that didn’t work, she threw it over the fence onto Grandpa. Scrambling to cover Mom’s obvious blunder, Linda only appeared to be surprised as well.
Mom had this conversation planned - just like most with her. She then immediately jumped to throwing Grandpa under the bus. She said, “My father used to climb in bed with me, and my mother let him. She knew it, and never did a thing. Well. He didn’t do anything. But he lay with me. How weird is that!”
Linda and I just looked at each other.
Mom continued. “Oh, he did a lot of weird things to me. He made me take my shirt off when I was sixteen working in the garden with him, and he made me take off my bra, too! Then he stood and watched me. Yeah! Oh, you don’t know the half of it. I never told anybody.”
Susie had already heard these stories at least a hundred times, growing up. But Susie loved Grandpa, and just always knew the stories were lies.
Back pedaling, Linda said, “There were good things about our childhood. We always knew the bills were paid.” She said a few other things that I believe were a stretch because for the life of me I can’t remember what they were. Then she ended up trying to calm Mom down as I slowly floated to the other end of the pool.
I was aggravated that Mom switched the subject and assaulted Grandpa. Wondering if it was something she made up on the fly, and knowing how Mom repeated her stories over and over, I asked Linda if she heard that story about Grandpa before. She said she didn’t know about Grandpa climbing into bed with her, but she remembered Mom telling her about Grandpa digging her poop out with a spoon when she was a child, and that is why she’s had vaginal and rectal fistulas her entire life.
I thought. How crazy is that?!!! I can’t imagine it ever happening. A spoon? No wonder Mom never told me that story, I would have never have believed it. The spoon story was even more unbelievable than the bed and the garden stories.
Too, I thought about how Linda played the supporting role for Mom once again. It made Mom ‘appear' more human - and as long as I could remember, Linda’s done this for Mom.